Cody Rhodes vs Randy Orton
Cody Rhodes won
Full results →
WWE profile
SmackDown · Men
Cody Rhodes returned to WWE as The American Nightmare, won consecutive Royal Rumbles and defeated Roman Reigns at WrestleMania XL.
Career guide reviewed
Official WWE profile ↗As listed by WWE · checked November 14, 2026.
Rhodes returned at WrestleMania 38 as Rollins' surprise opponent. Their rivalry continued into Hell in a Cell, where Rhodes wrestled with a torn pectoral muscle, a defining image of that comeback.
Royal Rumble wins in 2023 and 2024 gave Rhodes consecutive opportunities at WrestleMania. At WrestleMania XL, he defeated Reigns for the Undisputed WWE Championship, reaching the goal that had driven his return.
Up to 20 matches covered on this site (2026). This is not a complete career record. Results below contain spoilers.
Cody Rhodes won
Full results →Sami Zayn won
Full results →Cody Rhodes won
Full results →Cody Rhodes won
Full results →Cody Rhodes won
Full results →Kevin Owens won
Full results →Cody Rhodes won
Full results →Cody Rhodes won
Full results →Randy Orton won
Full results →CM Punk and Cody Rhodes won
Full results →Cody Rhodes and CM Punk won
Full results →CM Punk won
Full results →CM Punk won
Full results →Cody Rhodes won
Full results →CM Punk and Cody Rhodes won
Full results →Undisputed WWE Champion CM Punk won
Full results →Undisputed WWE Champion CM Punk won
Full results →Undisputed WWE Champion CM Punk & Cody Rhodes won
Full results →No contest
Full results →Cody Rhodes won
Full results →